Guide · Pitching craft
How to follow up with a journalist
Send one short follow-up, three to seven days after your pitch, as a reply in the same email thread, and give the reporter something new instead of asking whether they saw your first email. If there is still no answer after that, stop and put your energy into the next reporter or the next story.
The short version
- Wait three to seven days. Go sooner only when the news has a hard date, such as an embargo or an exclusive deadline.
- Reply in the original thread so the reporter sees your first pitch underneath, with the same subject line.
- Add one new thing: a fresh number, a customer who will talk, a chart, a date, or a sharper angle.
- Keep it under 100 words and end with one question they can answer yes or no.
- Follow up once, then stop. Silence after a follow-up is an answer.
- Do not call to ask whether they got your email.
What journalists say about follow-ups
Founders often worry that any follow-up is a nuisance. The surveys say otherwise: most reporters accept one, and very few want more than one.
- Once is the norm. In Cision's 2025 State of the Media research, 62% of journalists said a PR person should follow up once and only once, and fewer than 1 in 10 recommended more than one follow-up (Cision: what to know when following up on a pitch).
- The gap is days, not hours. Muck Rack's State of Journalism 2023 survey of 2,226 journalists found that 45% said one follow-up is ideal and 51% said it should come three to seven days after the pitch (Institute for Public Relations summary). Cision's research adds that about 3 in 10 journalists want two to three days to look over a pitch before anyone follows up.
- Mornings are better. Cision reports that journalists see 8 a.m. to noon as the best window for pitches and follow-ups, and before 8 a.m. or after 4 p.m. as the worst.
- Phone calls are unwelcome. On Muck Rack's 2025 State of Journalism webinar, both reporters on the panel said they prefer email and do not want cold calls, and one said a follow-up sent within three hours of the pitch is annoying (Muck Rack webinar FAQs).
The reason a single follow-up works is volume. Cision found that half of journalists receive more than 50 pitches a week. A good pitch can sink under the pile on a busy news day. A follow-up brings it back to the top once, at a better moment. A second and third follow-up just tell the reporter you are not reading their silence.
How a good follow-up is built
Think of the follow-up as a short sequel to the pitch, not a reminder. It has five parts, and each one has a job.
| Where it goes | A reply to your original email, so the subject line reads "Re:" plus your first subject and the full pitch sits underneath. The reporter should never have to search for what you are talking about. |
| First line | One sentence that names the story, not an apology. "Following up on the Fernway clinic data" is enough. |
| The new thing | The reason this email exists. A new figure, a customer or expert who has agreed to talk, a photo or chart, a confirmed date, or a tie to something the reporter published since your pitch. |
| The ask | One question with an easy answer: "Is this one for you?" or "Want the dataset?" Not "Let me know your thoughts." |
| The exit | A line that lets them say no without effort, and tells them you will not keep writing. This is what makes reporters comfortable replying at all. |
Keep the whole thing under 100 words. Cision suggests the follow-up should be shorter than the pitch itself, and the pitch should already be short. If you find yourself rewriting the full pitch in the follow-up, the first pitch needed work, and that is a lesson for the next reporter, not this one.
A worked example: before and after
Fernway is a fictional company that makes scheduling software for independent physical therapy clinics. Its founder pitched a health reporter a data story: no-show rates fell after clinics switched on text reminders. Five days later, no reply. Here is the follow-up most founders send, and a better one.
Before
Subject: Following up!
Hi, just bumping this to the top of your inbox. Did you get a chance to read my email about Fernway? We are really excited about what we are building and would love to get on your radar. Let me know your thoughts when you have a moment!
What is wrong: a new subject line breaks the thread, so the reporter has to hunt for the original. "Bumping this" and "did you get a chance" put the burden on the reporter. There is nothing new, nothing about the reader, and no clear question.
After
Subject: Re: New data: PT clinic no-shows fell 31% with text reminders, across 240 clinics
Hi [first name], one update on the clinic data below. Forty more clinics joined the sample this week and the drop held at 31%. Two clinic owners, in Ohio and Arizona, can talk Thursday or Friday. Is this one for you? If not, no problem, and I will not send more on it.
That is about 60 words. It stays in the thread, adds a real development, offers sources the reporter would need anyway, asks one question and closes the loop politely. All figures here are invented for the example. In a real follow-up, every number has to be one you can document.
Variations and special cases
The three-to-seven-day rule is the default. Some stories run on their own clock.
- Embargoed funding or launch news. Reporters need time to write. Send the pitch at least a week ahead, and if you follow up, do it two or three business days before the embargo lifts, not the morning of. A follow-up after the news is public is a new pitch, not a follow-up.
- An exclusive offer. Put a deadline in the original pitch ("I can hold this for you until Wednesday noon"). Follow up once, the day before it expires. When it passes, tell them you are taking it elsewhere and do so. Never offer the same exclusive to two reporters at once.
- A data or trend story. These have no hard date, so you can wait the full week. Your best follow-up adds a new cut of the data or a person who lives the trend.
- A reaction to breaking news. If you are offering comment on something in today's news, a follow-up the next day is usually too late. Pitch fast, once, and let it go.
- The reporter replied "not right now." That is not a no to you. Thank them, ask nothing, and come back only when you have a genuinely different story.
- The reporter wrote the story. Send a short thank-you with no ask. Share the piece. That reporter is now the easiest person to pitch next time, and a quiet thank-you is how you keep it that way.
What to do when there is still no reply
No answer after one follow-up means the story is not right for that reporter right now. It does not mean the story is bad. Move to the next reporter on your list with a pitch rewritten for their beat. Keep a simple log of who you pitched, when, the angle, and the result, so you never double-pitch the same person on the same news. Come back to a reporter who went quiet only when you have a new story, and give it at least a month or two.
If three or four well-matched reporters all pass or stay silent, look at the pitch before you look for more names. The usual culprits are a weak subject line, no number, or a story about your company rather than about something the reader cares about.
Common mistakes
- Following up within hours, or the next morning, on news with no deadline.
- Starting a new thread with a new subject line, so the original pitch is lost.
- Sending "just checking in" or "bumping this" with nothing new.
- Following up three, four or five times. Fewer than 1 in 10 journalists want more than one.
- Calling the newsroom or the reporter's phone to ask if they saw your email.
- Following up on social media or by text with a reporter you have never spoken to.
- Guilt or pressure: "I know you're busy, but" or "I haven't heard back."
- Copying several reporters at the same outlet on one follow-up, or forwarding the pitch to their editor.
- Following up with a reporter who already said no.
- Treating silence as a reason to send a longer email.
A quick checklist before you hit send
- Has it been at least three days, or is there a real deadline?
- Is it a reply in the original thread?
- Does it add one thing the first pitch did not have?
- Is it under 100 words, with one yes-or-no question?
- Is this your first and only follow-up on this story to this person?
Follow up with fewer reporters, and better ones
The easiest follow-up is the one you never need to send, because the first pitch went to someone who covers exactly your story. Describe your company in one sentence and see the 3 reporters most likely to cover it, with the angle to pitch each one. Free, no card.
See my 3 reportersRelated
- How to build a media list: who belongs on it, the columns to keep, and a before-and-after example.
- How to pitch a journalist: what reporters read first, with a before-and-after pitch.
- Pitch email subject lines that journalists open: a four-part formula with examples.
- How to announce your funding round.
- How to pitch Forbes: one writer, real news, no paid placements.
- What a press embargo is and how to use one: lift times, agreement first, and embargo vs. exclusive.
- How to find journalists who cover your industry: build a short list from recent stories, not a database dump.
FAQ
How long should you wait to follow up with a journalist?
Three to seven days for most stories. In Muck Rack's 2023 survey, 51% of journalists said a follow-up should come three to seven days after the pitch. Go sooner only when there is a real deadline, such as an embargo.
How many times should you follow up on a pitch?
Once. In Cision's 2025 research, 62% of journalists said to follow up once and only once, and fewer than 1 in 10 recommended more than one follow-up.
Is it OK to call a journalist to follow up?
Generally no. Most reporters prefer email, and unsolicited calls asking whether they saw a pitch are a common complaint. Call only if the reporter has told you a phone call is welcome.
Cision, Muck Rack and the Institute for Public Relations are named for reference only. Earned is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of them. Survey figures are as published by their sources; check the originals for method. No guide can guarantee coverage.