Guide · Pitching craft
How to build a media list
A good media list is a short spreadsheet of 15 to 40 named reporters whose recent stories sit right next to yours, with a note on why each one fits. Build it by starting from stories like yours, not from outlets, and check every name against what they published in the last few months.
The short version
- Write your story in one sentence and list the three or four audiences who would care about it.
- Find 10 to 20 recent articles about companies, problems or numbers like yours, and note who wrote each one.
- Check each reporter's last few months of bylines to confirm they still cover that beat at that outlet.
- Record one line per reporter on why your story fits, citing a specific article they wrote.
- Sort the list into tiers and keep it small: a few dozen good names beat a few hundred guesses.
- Pitch each person one to one, then update the list after every send, reply and story.
What a media list is, and what it is not
A media list is the set of journalists you plan to pitch for a specific story, plus the notes that tell you why each one is on it. It is closer to a sales prospect list than to an email blast list. Every row is a person you could explain, in a sentence, why you chose.
It is not a database export of everyone with "technology" in their job title. Founders often buy or download a list of a few thousand contacts, send the same note to all of them, and conclude that press does not work. The numbers explain why. Cision's 2026 State of the Media report, a survey of 1,899 journalists, found that 72% say fewer than a quarter of the pitches they receive are relevant (Cision, 2026 State of the Media press release). In Cision's write-up of the same research, 82% of reporters say relevance is a must-have before they will consider a story, and 72% say they will block PR people who spam them with irrelevant outreach (Cision, Why do journalists ignore your PR pitch?).
That last figure is the real cost of a bad list. A generic blast does not just fail this week. It can stop the right reporter from ever seeing your next, better story.
The columns that matter
A spreadsheet is enough. You do not need paid software to build your first list. Use these columns:
| Name and outlet | The person, and where they publish now. One row per person, not per outlet. |
| Beat | What they cover in their own recent work, in a few words, such as "health tech funding" or "small business, Ohio". |
| Proof article | The link to one recent story of theirs that makes your story a natural next one. |
| Why it fits | One sentence connecting your news to that article. If you cannot write it, the person does not belong on the list. |
| Tier | 1, 2 or 3, based on how much a story from them would matter to you. |
| How to reach them | Where they publicly ask to be pitched. Many reporters list a preferred route on their author page or social profile. |
| Status | Not pitched, pitched (date), followed up (date), replied, covered, or declined. |
The "Why it fits" column does most of the work. It forces you to read before you pitch, and the sentence you write there usually becomes the opening line of the pitch itself.
How to build one, step by step
1. Start from the story, not the outlet
Write the news in one plain sentence: "Fernway, a scheduling app for independent physical therapy clinics, has raised a $4M seed round and has data showing text reminders cut no-shows by 31%." Then list who would care. Here that is health business readers, small business readers, startup and venture readers, and readers in the city where Fernway is based. Each audience points to a different kind of outlet and a different reporter.
2. Search for stories like yours
For each audience, search for recent articles about similar companies, the same problem, or comparable numbers. Search news results for your category plus words like "raises", "launches" or "survey". Read the trade publications your customers read. Look up competitors and see who covered their announcements. Every article you find gives you a byline, and that byline is a candidate for the list.
Our guide on how to find journalists who cover your industry covers the search techniques in more detail.
3. Verify the beat with recent bylines
Before a name goes on the list, open the reporter's author page and read the headlines from the last few months. You are checking three things: they still work at that outlet, they still cover this subject, and they write the kind of story you are offering. A reporter who covered a funding round two years ago may now cover politics, or may have left the outlet.
Watch for reporters who now publish on their own. A 2025 Muck Rack study found that one in three journalists now self-publish independently, most often on personal websites or blogs (53%) and email newsletters (41%) (Muck Rack, State of Creator Journalism release). An independent newsletter that your exact customers read can be worth more than a big outlet where your story is a footnote, so give those writers a row too.
4. Write the "why it fits" line
For each reporter, write one sentence that names a specific story they wrote and how yours connects to it. "Wrote about hospital systems buying up independent PT clinics in March; our data shows how independents keep patients" is a good line. "Covers health tech" is not. If you only have the vague version, keep reading their work or take them off the list.
5. Tier and trim
Tier 1 is the handful of reporters whose story would matter most to your goals. Tier 2 are strong fits at outlets your audience reads. Tier 3 are good fits with smaller reach, such as trade newsletters and local business press. For most startup announcements, 15 to 40 names is plenty. If your list has hundreds of rows, most of them are probably guesses.
6. Pitch one to one and keep the list alive
Send each reporter a separate email that opens with your "why it fits" line. In Muck Rack's State of Journalism 2026, as summarized by the University of Minnesota, 62% of journalists said they prefer to be pitched in a one-to-one email, and 70% said clear relevance to their beat was what they valued most in a pitch (University of Minnesota, Pitching journalists with Muck Rack's State of Journalism 2026). After each send, update the Status column. A list you maintain becomes more valuable with every announcement. A list you rebuild from scratch each time does not.
A worked example: before and after
Fernway is a fictional company. Here are two versions of the same three rows from its media list. Outlet and reporter names are placeholders.
Before
Big Business Daily | Tech desk | general inbox
Startup News Site | Reporter A | "covers startups"
Health Weekly | Editor B | "health"
What is wrong: one row is an outlet, not a person. The other two have beats so broad they tell you nothing. There is no proof article, no reason the story fits, and no way to know if these people still cover the topic. A founder working from this list will send the same generic email to all three, which is the pitch most likely to be deleted.
After
Tier 1 | Health Business Journal | Reporter C | Beat: outpatient care business | Proof: March story on chains buying independent PT clinics | Fit: our 240-clinic data shows how independents keep patients | Route: email listed on author page | Not pitched
Tier 2 | City Business Weekly | Reporter D | Beat: local startups and funding | Proof: October roundup of local seed rounds | Fit: Fernway is based here and just closed a $4M seed | Route: tips form on author page | Not pitched
Tier 3 | Clinic Owner Newsletter (independent) | Writer E | Beat: running a PT practice | Proof: September issue on reducing no-shows | Fit: our no-show data answers the question her readers asked | Route: reply address in newsletter | Not pitched
Each row now names one person, shows a recent story that proves the fit, and has the first line of the pitch already written. The three rows also cover three different audiences: industry, local and the exact customers. All names and figures here are invented for the example.
Variations and special cases
- Funding announcement. Weight the list toward reporters who write about rounds in your sector or city. Business journals and venture newsletters often run short items that national outlets will not. See how to announce your funding round.
- Product launch. Add reviewers, trade publications and newsletters your buyers read. Launch lists are usually wider than funding lists because each vertical has its own press.
- Data story. Look for reporters who have quoted surveys or reports on your topic before. Original data is a strong hook: in the University of Minnesota summary of Muck Rack's 2026 report, 40% of journalists said they value original data or research in a pitch.
- Exclusive. Your list still matters, but you offer the story to one Tier 1 name at a time. If they pass, move down the list. Our guide on exclusive or wide release explains how.
- Local and regional press. Build a separate short list for your city and any city where you have many customers. Local reporters often care about hiring, headquarters and local customers more than about the product.
- Podcasts and newsletters. Treat them like outlets. Note the host or writer, a recent episode or issue that fits, and how they ask to be contacted.
- Timing. Refresh the list before every announcement. People change jobs and beats, and a list that was accurate in spring may be half wrong by autumn.
Common mistakes
- Listing outlets instead of people, then emailing a general newsroom address.
- Buying or downloading a large contact list and sending everyone the same email.
- Choosing reporters by outlet size rather than by what they actually write.
- Skipping the byline check, and pitching someone who left the beat or the outlet.
- Leaving the "why it fits" column blank and planning to write it later.
- Putting several reporters from one outlet on the same email, or pitching two of them at once without saying so.
- Ignoring trade, local and independent writers because they feel less impressive.
- Never updating the list, so the same people get pitched after they have declined twice.
- Collecting personal phone numbers or home addresses. Use the route each reporter publishes for pitches, and nothing else.
- Expecting the list to guarantee coverage. It only makes sure the right people see the story.
Start your list with three names
Describe your company in one sentence and see the 3 reporters most likely to cover it, with the angle to pitch each one. It is the top of your media list, done for you. Free, no card.
See my 3 reportersRelated
- How to find journalists who cover your industry: where to look and how to check a reporter's beat.
- How to pitch a journalist: what reporters read first, with a before-and-after pitch.
- How to follow up with a journalist: when to send one follow-up and what to put in it.
- Inc. 5000: a list worth tracking alongside your press list, with timing and eligibility.
- What to put in a startup press kit: the files, facts and quotes reporters need, and where to host them.
FAQ
How many journalists should be on a media list?
For most startup announcements, 15 to 40 well-chosen reporters is enough. Every name should have a recent article that shows why your story fits. A longer list usually means less research per name, not more coverage.
Should I buy a media list?
Paid databases can save time finding names, but a bought list is a starting point, not a finished list. You still need to check each reporter's recent work and write a reason they fit before you pitch them.
How often should I update my media list?
Before every announcement, and after every pitch. Check that each reporter still covers the beat at the same outlet, and record who replied, who covered you and who declined.
Cision, Muck Rack, the University of Minnesota and Inc. are named for reference only. Earned is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of them. Figures are as published at the links above; check the originals for changes. No guide can guarantee coverage.